Friday, March 23, 2012

Prison for Profit

       The U.S. has lead the way in business innovation for decades by branching out into previously untapped markets to go where others may not have thought to go.  While there are many examples of companies going into markets to create good, such as with renewable energy sources, there are a few areas that many, including myself, believe should be left to the state.  The privatization of prisons is an incredibly troubling prospect.  While many people claim that it is bad enough having a government body handle matters of depriving people of their liberty to punish them for committing crimes, putting that responsibility in the hands of businessmen begs numerous questions about the quality of the facilities and staff as well as the possible ramifications of a "prison for profit" system.  Before I explore these questions, I find that it would be beneficial to provide some statistics about this relatively new form of incarceration in the U.S.
       Most of the prisons in the United States are still controlled by the local, state, or federal government, but since the 1980's we have seen a rise in privately owned and operated facilities mostly in the southern and western regions of the U.S.  While most states only privatize certain aspects of their prisons such as laundry services and food preparation, the first example of an entirely privately owned and operated prison in the U.S. was in 1984 when the Corrections Corporation of America (CCA) was awarded a contract to take over a corrections facility in Hamilton County, Tennessee.  Only a year after, the CCA made a bold move by offering to take over the entire state of Tennessee's correctional program for $200 million.  Thankfully, due to strong opposition by state employees and concern from the state legislature, the CCA was denied this contract.  Although they were temporarily defeated in this case, the CCA as well as other private prison organizations continued to expand their market by opening 153 private correctional facilities by December of 2000.  The Sentencing Project, which has been a leader in researching and reforming sentencing and incarceration in the U.S. for 25 years, has reported that while the number of states having contracts with private prison companies has gone down between 1990 and 2010, the number of prisoners in private facilities has gone up dramatically.

       Today, private companies which include CCA, the GEO group, Inc (formerly known as Wackenhut Securities), and Community Education Centers, operate 264 correctional facilities, housing almost 99,000 adult convicts.  These private companies have also moved into the juvenile detention sector which, unlike the other branches of the corrections system, has a lot less safety risks involved.  While private juvenile detention centers sound ok due to the lower security risk and maintenance costs associated with them, the Sentencing Project noted that GEO’s Walnut Grove Youth Correctional Facility in Mississippi is the subject of a federal investigation into brutality complaints. A lawsuit against it alleges inmates “live in unconstitutional and inhumane conditions and endure great risks to their safety and security.”  This incident was thought to be caused by the higher employee turnover rates which are typically seen in these private institutions says the Sentencing Project.  The staff effectiveness in private organizations also exhibits a lack of maintaining security protocol with visitors and prisoners which includes insufficient guard patrols and other various security risks.  These security problems led to a prison break from an Arizona facility in which three dangerous convicts escaped and fled to Colorado where they killed a married couple before being arrested in Rifle, Colorado.

       While the obvious security risks and living conditions in these private facilities are obvious due to their goal of lowering the bottom line, another concern looms overhead which is more troubling than the rest.  The issue that I am concerned with is that if we get our prison system privatized, how long until we have inmate quotas in order to fill these prisons for the companies to make money?  This could lead to private police being created which round up individuals for various "crimes" in order to ensure profitability for these companies.  I know this idea seems pretty far-fetched, but then again, I never thought that I would see the day when prisons would be run by businesses.  This "prison-for-profit" system may very well be a slippery slope that takes us to a place that would spit on the laws and liberty that we hold so dear.   Private prisons such as the Baldwin prison in Michigan had three times as many violent incidents as the state’s other maximum security facilities.  Is this risk really worth the "savings" that the government would see in this depressed economy?  The private companies have enticed states with slashing the costs of incarcerating individuals, but where do those savings come from?  From my experience it comes from understaffing, poor food and living conditions, and overcrowded facilities which offer very little, if any, benefit from the current system.

For more information on the Sentencing Project, visit their website at:


  1. This was a very informative post. I have never put a whole lot of thought into the privatization of prisons, but after reading your post I now realize the large downside to this idea. It is quite frightening to read how inmates are treated in these facilities. Private firms seem to be out for their own selfish goals, to make a profit, while inmate rights are ignored. The right against cruel and unusual punishment seems to be thrown out the window when a company is making money.

    It is a scary reality that more privately run prisons and possibly privately organized police departments could begin to appear with the economy the way it is. I can imagine Govern Quinn being open to the idea of privatizing prisons in our state to save money. We are talking about the man who is planning on closing both Dwight and Tamms prisons. The reason these institutions may close is due to the debts our great state has accumulated. I am sure lobbyist in Springfield could convince the governor to hand over prison operations to private firms for a profit. If our state does decide to close prisons and layoff law enforcement employees, inmates will have to be sent somewhere other than the other overly populated prisons within the state.

    It certainly could be a reality to see more privately operated prisons and police agencies in the near future. As long as politicians feel they can save money or possibly make a buck in the process, I am sure they will continue to be opened to the idea. Unfortunately, inmates and public safety could be jeopardized by the inability of these private agencies to operate prisons at a reasonable and lawful standard. Only time will tell which direction prison operations will go in. I only hope the states do what is best for the well-being of inmates and the safety of society.

  2. I really enjoyed reading your post because I have taken an interest in privatized prisons. They have good things about them but mostly I would say that they have more negative aspects than positive.

  3. I have never agreed with Prison for Profit. It seems inherently wrong to me that people could make money off of confining and controlling people in a prison. It may take some burden off the states and federal government financially but it also exposes prisoners to the rule of the prison owner. Federal and state government have little to no control how the prison is ran and who the staff is. And like any business its all about profiting so who knows what they will do to keep the profit up? Lobby for harder laws to make sure their prisons stay full?

  4. Find out how 1,000's of people like YOU are working for a LIVING online and are living their wildest dreams right NOW.

  5. You may be qualified for a new government sponsored solar energy program.
    Find out if you qualify now!

  6. eToro is the #1 forex trading platform for beginner and pro traders.